A newly found 29-foot-long tyrannosaur flashed more teeth than the well-known Tyrannosaurus rex, with which it shared a common ancestor, according to a paper in the latest Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology.Remains of the badlands dinosaur, Bistahieversor sealeyi, were collected in the first paleontological excavation from a federal wilderness area, the Bisti/De-na-zin Wilderness of New Mexico. The dino's remains were removed VIP-style, airlifted by a helicopter operated by the Air Wing of the New Mexico Army National Guard."Bistahieversor sealeyi is the first valid new genus and species of tyrannosaur to be named from western North America in over 30 years," said co-author Thomas Williamson, curator of paleontology at the New Mexico Museum of Natural History.It lived 74-75 million years ago, close to 10 million years before T. rex emerged. The earliest known tyrannosaurs date to about 167 million years ago and came from the American West, according to Carr. It is now therefore believed that the rough and tumble Tyrannosauridae family was born in the U.S.A.Several features distinguish the new dinosaur, according to Williamson's partner on the project, Thomas Carr, who is director of the Carthage Institute of Paleontology and an assistant professor of biology at Carthage College.It had around 64 teeth, while adult T. rex, had just 54.
Saturday, January 30, 2010
New Species of Tyrannosaur Discovered in Southwestern U.S.
Friday, January 29, 2010
Haplocheirus, the alvarezsauroid that looked normal
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/327/5965/571Jonah N. Choiniere, X. Xu, J.M. Clark, C.A. Forster, Y. Guo, F. Han. 2010. A
Basal Alvarezsauroid Theropod from the Early Late Jurassic of Xinjiang,
China. Science 327:571-574 DOI: 10.1126/science.1182143The fossil record of Jurassic theropod dinosaurs closely related to birds remains poor. A new theropod from the earliest Late Jurassic of western China represents the earliest diverging member of the enigmatic theropod group Alvarezsauroidea and confirms that this group is a basal member of Maniraptora, the clade containing birds and their closest theropod relatives. It extends the fossil record of Alvarezsauroidea by 63 million years and provides evidence for maniraptorans earlier in the fossil record than Archaeopteryx. The new taxon confirms extreme morphological convergence between birds and derived alvarezsauroids and illuminates incipient stages of the highly modified alvarezsaurid forelimb.
A newly discovered dinosaur species is helping paleontologists figure out how bird-like characteristics evolved in dinosaurs that aren't directly related to birds.The dinosaur, Haplocheirus sollers, was three-metres long with short, powerful arms and three claws on each hand. It is an early member of the alvarezsaur family, a strange group of dinosaurs characterized by stubby forelimbs and hands reduced to a single claw.Haplocheirus is 63 million years older than any other members of its family, helping to clear up the evolution of the meat-eating dinosaurs, the theropods, which includes velociraptors and T. rex."Haplocheirus is a transitional fossil, because it shows an early evolutionary step in how the bizarre hands of later alvarezsaurs evolved from earlier predatory dinosaurs," said Jonah Choiniere of George Washington University, in a statement.
Fall of dishonest doctor who started MMR/autism scare
Monday, January 4, 2010
Climategate: "The stink of intellectual corruption is overpowering"
Most haven’t read the emails or summarily dismiss them because of political bias. Journalist Clive Crook illustrated an open mind, albeit on second look. “In my previous post on Climategate I blithely said that nothing in the climate science email dump surprised me much. Having waded more deeply over the weekend I take that back. The closed-mindedness of these supposed men of science, their willingness to go to any lengths to defend a preconceived message, is surprising even to me. The stink of intellectual corruption is overpowering.”
Friday, January 1, 2010
Yet more extreme Triassic weirdness: Vancleavea
Thursday, October 22, 2009
So Ida wasn't the discovery that changed everything after all
IT WAS billed as one of the most important fossil finds in history, a "missing link" that would challenge everything we knew about human evolution.
Darwinius masillae, the primitive primate that was unveiled to the world with huge fanfare and a Sir David Attenborough documentary in May, seems now to have been less of a missing link than an evolutionary dead end. Far from being an ancestor to humans, the lemur-like creature from 47 million years ago belongs to an entirely different branch of the primate family tree that has left no known descendants, research has indicated.
When Jorn Hurum, of the University of Oslo Natural History Museum, announced the discovery of the astonishingly well-preserved fossil, he described it as "the first link to all humans". He nicknamed the animal "Ida" after his daughter, and a promotional website, a film and a book claimed that she could have been the common ancestor of all modern monkeys and apes, a relic of a critical branching moment in human evolution. Sir David, who narrated the documentary, said: "This little creature is going to show us our connection with the rest of all mammals. The link they would have said until now is missing, is no longer missing."
The discovery of fossils of another similar animal from 37 million years ago has now cast grave doubt on that idea. Both Darwinius masillae and the new primate, Afradapis longicristatus, appear to belong to a different lineage, closer to lemurs than monkeys and apes, that died out without modern descendants.
Saturday, October 3, 2009
The Milky Way in a New Light
Friday, October 2, 2009
Vaccinated British teenager killed by tumour NOT the vaccine
Ardipithecus ramidus, human evolution & scientific hype
At long last, meet Ardipithecus ramidusIda was a lemur-like primate that lived 47 million years ago in an area that is now Messel, Germany. Ardi was much closer to us; she was one of the earliest hominins and lived 4.4 million years ago in what would become known as Ethiopia.When the bones of Ida were discovered they were held in a private collection for years before being sold for an undisclosed sum to paleontologist Jorn Hurum. The first bones of Ardi were found in the field in 1992 by paleoanthropologist Gen Suwa. Enough fossils were found for an initial publication two years later, but the search continued for years afterward. That search has yielded over 100 bones from Ardi's kind, representing about 36 individuals. Ardi is the most complete individual, with about 45% of the skeleton intact.From almost the time of her acquisition by Hurum, Ida was groomed to be a star. The media company Atlantic Productions began to work with Hurum and immediately started the production of a book, several documentaries, and a bombastic public unveiling of a discovery they said would "CHANGE EVERYTHING." The scientists describing Ida were forced to rush their study to meet the deadline set by the company The bones of Ardi and her kin, by contrast, were scrutinized with great detail over 15 years. So secret was the study of her bones that some frustrated paleoanthropologists called it the "Manhattan Project of anthropology."Ida was introduced to the public as the "ancestor of us all", but the science behind this claim was flimsy. She was more closely related to lemurs than to us. Ardi, however, sits relatively close to the base of the human (i.e. hominin) family tree. Whether our species can trace its ancestral heritage back through hers will be something that will be debated in the months and years to come, but she is nevertheless one of our closest extinct relatives.Ardi, of course, is short for Ardipithecus ramidus, one of the earliest hominins found to date. Her skeleton (see image below), as well as bits and pieces of other skeletons of the same species, were described this week in a special edition of the journal Science.
Thursday, October 1, 2009
Discover Magazine: most cancer caused by viruses?
Paul Ewald says infections are responsible for at least four-fifths of all cancers—and we have the tools to prevent them.
by Andrew Grant
From the New Science of Health special issue, published online September 30, 2009
Monday, July 20, 2009
Clive Hamilton sits in the lotus position and chants Omm
So I think where we’re going is to begin to see a Gaian earth in its ecological, cybernetic way, infused with some notion of mind or soul or chi, which will transform our attitudes to it away from an instrumentalist one, towards an attitude of greater reverence. I mean, the truth is, unless we do that, I mean we seriously are in trouble, because we know that Gaia is revolting against the impact of human beings on it.
EU casts doubt on health claims of "super foods"
EU inquiry pours doubt on benefit of health foods
More than 50 food products and supplements have been exposed by a Europe-wide investigation for making unproven claims about their health benefits.Ocean Spray cranberry juice, Lipton black tea and some probiotic supplements are among the items whose claimed health benefits are scientifically unproven, according to an investigation by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA).Fish oil supplements which purport to improve brain growth in babies and children have come under particular scrutiny, with the agency rejecting most of the benefits claimed by manufacturers.The initial results of the inquiry suggest that consumers could be wasting millions of pounds each year on products they think will improve their diet and lifestyle.
Saturday, June 20, 2009
Science guy provides iffy links
| From Jeff Beck: Sage advice from Tim Lambert: always click on the links. When reading Lambert always click on his links; you'll likely find they don't support whatever argument he's making. The following is typical: The use of DDT against malaria is not banned. The LD50 (quantity that kills half of test subjects) for DDT is 200 mg/kg for monkeys (closest analogue to humans). So for a 75 kg person that's 15g, or one tablespoon. A 50% chance of killing you does not, to me, seem to be the same as "no harm at all". And DDT does thin bird shells... The first link above is to an earlier Lambert post with further links to other Lambert posts. These address not the general use of DDT but rather Sri Lanka's use of DDT in the 1960s and '70s. The second link is to the Pesticide Action Network's pesticide database -- apparently Lambert could find no reputable science sources providing the information he needed. Full post here. |
Wednesday, June 10, 2009
Evidence birds did not evolve from dinosaurs?
I don't think so.
John Ruben is a well known BANDit. BAND = birds are not dinosaurs. This is allied to ABSRD (pronounced "absurd"), or anything but a small running dinosaur.
Membership of these groups is comprised of people who "know" that birds could not have evolved from dinosaurs, and are on a ceaseless quest to try and find evidence to support this "knowledge."
They "know" that feathers had to have evolved for flight directly and that flight evolved from the trees down, not the ground up.
But these are a priori beliefs, not facts established by evidence.
They are also a salutary lesson that clever and well educated people, experts in their own way and in their own fields, can also be very wrong about things and almost wilfully so.
On any reckoning of the available evidence, the case that birds are highly derived theropod dinosaurs is overwhelming. (Theropods were the two-legged carnivorous dinosaurs. A group ranging from the immense T rex to the tiny microraptor.)
It is now absolutely clear that feathers did evolve in the context of becoming volent, but were exapted for that purpose. Exaptation is where a character that originally fulfilled another function is put to another use.
While we can never be certain about these things, (the Deep Time problem makes this impossible), it does seem that primitive filamentous feathers, akin (but probably not exactly the same) to those found on Kiwis evolved with the Theropoda long before the first theropod became the first bird, and probably for the purpose of insulation.
We now have numerous fossils of what are clearly dinosaurs covered in this "dino-fuzz." But even more astounding, (and how the BANDits reconcile this with their views is simply beyond me), we have many fossils now of again unequivocal dinosaurs not only covered in this fuzz, but also with modern looking feathers adorning their arms and tails. Other than being symmetrical rather than asymmetrical (for those on the arms), they are identical to the flight and body feathers found on modern birds.
Now, these are mostly maniraptorans. Velociraptor was such a creature, as was oviraptosaurus and its kin.
However, one of the very first of the animals discovered in China covered in dino-fuzz, Sinosauropteryx prima, was not a maniraptoran.
It was a primitive compsognathid dinosaur. A "living fossil," (yes I know the term is very suspect, but you get my drift), even in its own day. This would indicate that feathers or their antecedents evolved much earlier on and further back along the dinosaur family tree than people had previously imagined, and that such structures were widespread amongst several lineages within the Theropoda.
You really would think that this would close the case on this question. But never underestimate people's ability to believe what they want to believe and build elaborate houses of cards to support it.
It's not just UFO enthusiasts or 9/11 conspiracy cranks who do this.
So the BANDits start looking further back in time to search for any poorly preserved reptile that has some vaguely avian characteristic which they then cite as a possible contender as an ancestor to birds. And at times by vague, I really do mean vague. A somewhat triangular skull is put forward as indicating possible avian affinities.
That some of these reptiles don't appear to be anywhere near to the archosaurs, the group of diapsid reptiles that birds, (along with crocodilians and dinosaurs), clearly belong to, doesn't seem to faze them.
That they can't give a plausible evolutionary line from said primitive reptile to birds supported by any fossil evidence, doesn't seem to faze then either. The argument runs something like this - "this Triassic reptile has some vague similarity to modern birds and somehow, we don't know how though, may have given rise to them.
"We just know however that birds didn't evolve from theropod dinosaurs and therefore something like this must have been the ancestor."
Not a particularly strong argument I'd suggest.
Here are some artists' interpretation of the modern understanding of maniraptoran dinosaurs, oviraptosaurs in this case:
These are dinosaurs.
Thursday, June 4, 2009
When a randomised, controlled clinical trial isn't one at all
First definitive carcharodontosaurid from Asia
Shaochilong maxilla (top), braincase (middle) and skull roof (bottom) from Brusatte et al., 2009.
"While in Beijing I figured I should try to see the specimen, as some authors had suggested that it was a tyrannosauroid or a basal coelurosaur of some kind. Either way, it would provide important data for my thesis. But when I opened the drawer and saw the maxilla and braincase staring back at me, I quickly realized something was wrong. “C.” maortuensis is not a coelurosaur, but possesses a number of unique features seen in Carchrodontosaurus, Giganotosaurus, Mapusaurus, and Acrocanthosaurus—colossal theropods closely related to Allosaurus that are grouped within their own subclade, the Carcharodontosauridae (the shark-toothed reptiles, named for obvious reasons)."
Archosaur Musings
The new name given to this animal, Shaochilong, "meaning “shark teeth dragon” in Chinese, [is an] obvious reference to the carcharodontosaurids."
Brusatte, S., Benson, R., Chure, D., Xu, X., Sullivan, C., & Hone, D.(2009). The first definitive carcharodontosaurid (Dinosauria: Theropoda) from Asia and the delayed ascent of tyrannosaurids Naturwissenschaften DOI: 10.1007/s00114-009-0565-2
Abstract: Little is known about the evolution of large-bodied theropod dinosaurs during the Early to mid Cretaceous in Asia. Prior to this time, Asia was home to an endemic fauna of basal tetanurans, whereas terminal Cretaceous ecosystems were dominated by tyrannosaurids, but the intervening 60 million years left a sparse fossil record. Here, we redescribe the enigmatic large-bodied Chilantaisaurus maortuensis from the Turonian of Inner Mongolia, China. We refer this species to a new genus, Shaochilong, and analyze its systematic affinities. Although Shaochilong has previously been allied with several disparate theropod groups (Megalosauridae, Allosauridae, Tyrannosauroidea, Maniraptora), we find strong support for a derived carcharodontosaurid placement. As such, Shaochilong is the first unequivocal Asian member of Carcharodontosauridae, which was once thought to be restricted to Gondwana. The discovery of an Asian carcharodontosaurid indicates that this clade was cosmopolitan in the Early to mid Cretaceous and that Asian large-bodied theropod faunas were no longer endemic at this time. It may also suggest that the ascent of tyrannosaurids into the large-bodied dinosaurian predator niche was a late event that occurred towards the end of the Cretaceous, between the Turonian and the Campanian.
Saturday, May 30, 2009
Virtual fossils reveal how ancient creatures lived
BEHIND the war of words over the significance of Ida, the 47-million-year-old primate fossil unveiled last week, a quiet revolution in palaeontolgy is unfolding. Thanks to a souped-up version of a technique better known for its use in medical diagnostics, we are gaining unprecedented insights into the way prehistoric creatures lived, breathed and grew.
The technique is X-ray computed tomography (CT). Though X-rays have been used to look into fossils since this type of radiation was discovered in 1895, the flat images it produced changed little over the following century. As recently as 2004, a review in The British Journal of Radiology (vol 77, p 420) saw little merit in X-ray images of fossils beyond acting as a guide to palaeontologists chipping away the rock encasing them.
CT changes all that.
Full article here New Scientist
Friday, May 29, 2009
Weighing the risks of vaccinating children for whooping cough
| Sandy from Junkfood Science begins: "Loving parents have a hard job. They want to protect their children from harm and make the best healthcare decisions for them, but with all of the health information and misinformation swirling around, it can seem impossible to know what to believe. One question for some parents is whether childhood immunizations are necessary anymore. With fewer children dying of childhood illnesses today, it can seem like the diseases are no longer serious and that the vaccines might be putting their children at needless risk." Unfortunately there is a lot of uninformed and downright ignorant false information about childhood vaccination circulating these days, but some acknowledgement needs to be paid to sceptical parents. They do want to do what is best for their children, and they are trying to inform themselves about the risks associated with vaccines. And we do need to be up front and honest with them - there are levels of risk with any medication. No medecine is without some possible side effects. (Though unfortunately we also have irresponsible and scientifically illiterate conspiracy pushers, as seen with the claims of a MMR vaccine and autism link. Complete rubbish that has been shown conclusively to be totally untrue.) But what these parents always seem to fail to do is try and understand the risks of not vaccinating children. So what are the risks of not vaccinating children relative to vaccinating them? Research just published in the June issue of Pediatrics looks specifically at pertussis, or whooping cough. The results speak for themselves: They...look[ed] at every case of pertussis infection identified in children in the Kaiser Permanente of Colorado health plan over more than a decade, between 1996 and 2007. They randomly matched each case to four controls and looked at the children’s vaccination records. The differences were striking. Only 0.5% of the healthy children had not been vaccinated, compared to 12% of the children who had gotten sick with pertussis. You can read the whole thing by following the link at the top. So parents need to balance concern about either small or false risks from vaccines themselves against the increased risk that their child will get a serious disease that may even kill him. See also Lessons from the Vaccine-Autism Wars I'd also urge anyone interested to follow her links in relation to "tenable correlations" and "relative risks". These are absolutely vital in sorting the wheat from the chaff when it comes to assessing claims in the media about some study claiming to have found some link or other. All studies are not the same. The number that are poorly conducted pseudo-scientific rubbish with weak findings, but yet get saturation coverage in the media is not only astounding, it is depressing. Recent claims about red meat, alcohol and high GI diets causing cancer and other illnesses all fall into this category. Claims are made about the health implications for the general population based upon samples that are not representative of the general population. The red meat gives you cancer nonsense recently peddled by naive and credulous journalists was a particularly egregious example. In this case, the sample was formed by those members of the American Association of Retired Persons, ages 50 to 71, who could be bothered to fill out and post back a questionairre sent to them way back in 1995. (So yes, no new research at all was done for this study. It simply involved feeding the prior collected information through a computer that looked for correlations - hence the importance of understanding the difference between tenable and untenable correlations.) What this means is that they were using an unrepresentative sample of an unrepresentative sample! Why this wasn't setting off alarm bells for people is beyond me. Though I suspect that in truth, nobody bothered to check. Correlation does not equal causation. Seems simple enough, but not for many of these researchers. The number of findings based on untenable correlations is appalling. If you seach through any large enough data set, you will find correlations. Whether these correlations mean anything or are just the result of chance is another question entirely. All too often it is these simple correlations that form the basis of press releases claiming to have found a link between our food and disease. Then we have press releases claiming such links when the study's own data says something different. Again, the recent red meat study stands out for claims that were simply not supported by its own results. Despite the headlines shrieking that high red meat consumption increased your risk of getting cancer, examination of its results said something else. While claimed rates for a number of cancers for men who who ate the most red meat were higher than those who ate the least, the difference between the two groups was only 1.4%. Now, I'm guessing, (and yes, this is a guess, but I'm prepared to put money on it), but I suspect that this falls within the study's own margin of error and thus statistically there is no real difference. However, when it came to women, those with the highest consumption of red meat had lower rates of cancer compared to those with the lowest! A question arising from this is: why did the study's authors then issue a press release that claimed to have found a clear link between higher rates of red meat consumption and cancer, when their own results said the opposite? (Not that any of this study's results should be taken seriously I'd hasten to add. It is rubbish from beginning to end.) Part of the answer here is I believe the fact that health is one of those things that has replaced sex as the besetting concern of moral entrepreneurs. They already "know" that red meat, alcohol, high GI diets, fat etc are "bad" and they need to be seen to be sending the "right" message. This was obvious with the recent no safe level of drinking for women study conducted in the UK. You can see the author's predetermined determination to find that alcohol is bad for women, even at moderate levels, and then her consternation at finding that her results don't support her belief. So she reworks the data this way and that, trying to get the "right" result. In the end she fails. Her own data clearly shows that fully 95% of women who drank had lower rates of cancer compared to those who didn't. Only the top 5% heaviest drinkers had poorer health outcomes. But what does she announce to the media? The "right" result, ie that there is no safe level of alcohol consumption for women. Now, call me old fashioned, but I would have thought that the right result is what your data actually shows, not what you think it should show. |
Thursday, May 28, 2009
ABN Newswire interviews Ian Plimer
The BBC, Mad Cows Disease and climate change
After many years of sporadic interest the BSE/vCJD story took off in 1996 after an admission in parliament by the health minister that there was a link between BSE contaminated meat and a new strain of the degenerative vCJD brain disease that had afflicted a handful of people. Initially, few people knew anything definite about the disease and its possible progression and, depending upon assumptions, computer models predicted anything from a small number of people being affected to a large fraction of the population. While such uncertainty existed it was right for journalists to reflect the scientific situation but as I was science correspondent for BBC Radio at the time, I soon began to realise the tension between science and journalism and the changing approach to science within BBC News at the time.
In terms of news the potential for a modern day catastrophic plague is a much 'better' story than the possibility that nothing much more will happen. So whilst the uncertainty persisted that was the story that was emphasised with the appropriate caveats. However, it soon became clear to most scientists at least that a major catastrophe was not in the making. The increase in numbers afflicted, despite the unknown incubation of the disease, was not increasing as some predicted, but that fact was inconvenient to some and did not impinge on our general approach to the story.
In such circumstances I took the view that journalists should stay close to the data and not let the scientific possibilities, however dramatic and 'newsworthy,' obscure what was actually happening, especially when those possibilities rested on a cascade of debateable assumptions being fed into a computer model that had been tweaked to hindcast previous data. It was not a point of view taken by other arms of the BBC one part of which was repeatedly promoting the same scare story coming out of one institution based on said computer models and predictions. I believed that taking a sober approach was the right one, especially for the BBC, which was looked to for responsible reporting. Wanting to get on air with a story and make an impression with editors and management was one thing, but I took the view that a journalist should not tailor the science to suit ones ambitions, or survival, that way. The political journalist John Sergeant summed it up when he said that there were many journalists who reported what they could get away with rather than what they know.
My approach was not favoured by the BBC at the time and I was severely criticised in 1998 and told I was wrong and not reporting the BSE/vCJD story correctly. But with hindsight I was correct in my approach. To date the total number of people afflicted with BSE/vCJD remains very small. In fact, far smaller than many illnesses that never get a mention in the media, and the scientific doom mongers have moved onto new pastures. But the attitude towards science still remains at the BBC and has been evident in its evangelical, inconsistent climate change reporting and its narrow, shallow and sparse reporting on other scientific issues.
Reporting the consensus about climate change (and we all know about the debate about what is a consensus in the IPCC era) is not synonymous with good science reporting. The BBC is at an important point. It has been narrow minded about climate change for many years and they have become at the very least a cliché and at worst lampooned as being predictable and biased by a public that doesn't believe them anymore.
Times are changing. New data is emerging, the world refuses to warm in the past decade, the sun becomes quiet, and scientists are beginning to study themselves investigating how entrenched positions become established and whether consensus is a realistic concept. History and science will always correct things in the end. It has done so with vCJD and it is not impossible that the judgement of history and science on current environmental reporting will be the same.
SOURCE